Most people assume the key to a higher Social Security payment is earning a high income. But that’s not actually the biggest driver. The system is designed so that a few specific decisions have a much larger impact than most people expect. In fact, most of the improvement comes from factors that are within your control, not just how much you earn.
Your highest 35 years matter more than anything else
Social Security is based on your best 35 years of earnings, adjusted to today’s dollars and averaged out. That average becomes the starting point for your benefit.
If you work fewer than 35 years, the system fills in the missing years with zeros, which pulls your average down. This is why consistently working – and replacing lower-income years with higher ones over time – can make a meaningful difference.
It’s also important to remember that these are your best 35 years. As your income grows later in your career, those higher-earning years can replace earlier, lower-earning years and gradually lift your average.
You don’t need a massive income to get a strong benefit
A common misconception is that you need to earn a very high salary to get close to the maximum Social Security payment.
In reality, the system is progressive. It replaces a higher percentage of income at lower levels and a smaller percentage at higher levels. That means while earning more does increase your benefit, the impact becomes less significant at higher income levels.
This structure is intentional. It helps balance outcomes and allows people with moderate incomes to still receive a meaningful benefit, even if they never reach top earning levels.
Plan Your Retirement With the Best Financial Planning Software I’ve Found
Get a two week FREE trial of Boldin (formerly NewRetirement) personal financial planning software if you decide to keep it, then it’s only $12/mo (billed annually) – use our affiliate link: https://go.Boldin.com/HolySchmidt to see if it’s for you.
When you claim has a major impact
One of the most powerful levers is timing. The longer you wait to claim Social Security, the larger your monthly benefit becomes.
Your benefit increases each year you delay, particularly between full retirement age and age 70. These increases are meaningful and can compound over time, especially if you live longer than expected.
For many people, this becomes one of the most impactful decisions they make. A higher guaranteed monthly income later in life can provide more stability and reduce pressure on other investments.
The system rewards consistency more than extremes
Social Security is not designed to reward a few high-income years as much as it rewards steady earnings over time.
Because your benefit is based on an average, having consistent income across your working years matters more than short periods of very high earnings. A long, stable earning history tends to produce better results than a more uneven one.
Understanding the formula gives you an advantage
Most people never take the time to understand how Social Security is actually calculated. Instead, they rely on general advice from friends, family, or articles that may not apply to their situation.
But once you understand the core formula – your best 35 years, adjusted for inflation and averaged – you start to see where the real opportunities are. That understanding alone can help you make better decisions over time.
You have more control than you think
While you can’t control everything, the biggest drivers of your Social Security benefit are largely within your control.
How long you work, how your earnings progress, and when you decide to claim all play a role. Even small adjustments in these areas can lead to meaningful differences in your final outcome.
Bottom line
Maximizing Social Security isn’t just about earning more – it’s about understanding how the system works and using that knowledge to your advantage. The biggest gains often come from decisions you can control, not just income alone. The more intentional you are with these levers, the stronger and more predictable your retirement income can be over time.
All the Best,
Geoffrey Schmidt, CPA
RECOMMENDED RESOURCES
Confused about how to make the best Social Security decision for you? Get Geoff’s course, Social Security Simplified and go from beginner to confident is less than 5 hours. Learn more by clicking here.
Talk to our partner, CHAPTER, the only Medicare Advisor we recommend. CHAPTER provides friendly, unbiased recommendations on over 24,000 plans – always 100% Free. Call 440-703-1224 or click here: http://askchapter.org/schmidt – tell them Geoff Schmidt sent you!
Holy Schmidt! YouTube Channel
You can find over 300 of our retirement-related videos at: https://www.youtube.com/holyschmidt
(If you haven’t done so already, please make sure you Subscribe 🙂 ).
Center For Retirement Research at Boston College
CRR is one of the best websites if you want in depth retirement data – I use it frequently. You can find it here: https://crr.bc.edu/
Note some of the companies in this newsletter are affiliate relationships. This means if you purchase a product or use their service, we earn a small commission. This does not increase your cost.
Forward to a Friend
If you know someone who can use this information, don’t forget to forward it to them. Also, ask them to sign up for The Schmidt List to get a copy of our free retirement-ready checklist: https://HolySchmidt.com/Checklist
About Geoff Schmidt
Geoff is an award-winning author, frequent public speaker, and CPA. He is a Registered Social Security Analyst (RSSA) and spent 25 years on Wall Street working at firms such as Deutsche Bank and Nomura. He has an MBA from the Kellogg School of Management at Northwestern University and is considered one of the foremost advocates for retirees and Social Security.
Disclaimer: The contents of this email are for education and entertainment purposes only. The content is also subject to errors, missing information and is not the complete body of work on the subject. This newsletter should not be used as a substitute for financial, tax, health, or other professional advice. If you need help in any of these areas seek the help of a competent professional. Not affiliated with the Social Security Administration
Chapter Disclaimer: Chapter and its affiliates are not connected with or endorsed by any government entity or the federal Medicare program. Chapter Advisory, LLC represents Medicare Advantage HMO, PPO, and PFFS organizations and stand alone prescription drug plans that have a Medicare contract. Enrollment depends on the plan’s contract renewal While we have a database of every Medicare plan nationwide and can help you to search among all plans, we have contracts with many but not all plans. As a result, we do not offer every plan available in your area. Currently we represent 50 organizations which offer 18,160 products nationwide. We search and recommend all plans, even those we don’t directly offer. You can contact a licensed Chapter agent to find out the number of products available in your specific area. Please contact Medicare.gov, 1-800-Medicare, or your local State Health Insurance Program (SHIP) to get information on all of your option.[1]
