In recent years, misinformation about Social Security has become widespread. This influx of questionable information, often presented as fact, stems from various sources—conversations among individuals, politically motivated statements, click-driven media headlines, or writers unknowingly creating confusion with poorly phrased titles. Regardless of the source, misleading information about Social Security can cause unnecessary panic.
The Problem with Misleading Headlines
Consider this recent example: a reputable news organization ran a headline stating, “Social Security’s Full Retirement Age is Increasing in 2025. Here’s What to Know.” Many readers might interpret this as a sudden policy change or a politically driven decision. However, this increase has been scheduled since 1983 – as part of the 1983 Social Security Amendments. A more accurate headline would have been, “1983 Social Security Act’s Annual Full Retirement Age Increase is on Schedule for 2025.”
While the first is technically correct, the headline implies urgency and controversy, whereas the latter provides necessary context. Unfortunately, sensationalized headlines tend to attract more clicks, even if they mislead readers.
If you’ve felt alarmed by headlines about Social Security, rest assured. In this article, we’ll dispel some common myths to help you understand what’s true and what’s not—culminating in debunking the most pervasive myth of all.
Myth 1: You Can Collect Social Security Without Contributing
This myth is partially true under specific circumstances. Dependents, such as spouses and children under a certain age, can collect Social Security benefits tied to a primary insured individual’s contributions. Additionally, the U.S. has something called “Totalization Agreements” with certain countries. These agreements allow individuals who’ve worked abroad and paid into another country’s Social Security system to combine credits for eligibility.
However, in the US this applies to a very small group—just 223,000 people as of 2022, compared to 54.3 million total Social Security recipients. Most of these individuals are likely U.S. citizens who worked temporarily abroad and later returned, though the SSA does not deconstruct the data further.
For the vast majority, eligibility for Social Security retirement benefits requires meeting specific work and contribution requirements. Your benefits are directly linked to your lifetime earnings on record with the SSA (and IRS).
Myth 2: Social Security Will Cover All Your Retirement Needs
This is a dangerous misconception. On average, Social Security covers only 40% of a retiree’s cost of living. While this percentage was higher in the mid-20th century, rising life expectancy and living costs have reduced its contribution. Also, we just consume more as a society in 2025 that we did in say, 1965.
To maintain your desired lifestyle in retirement, you’ll likely need supplemental income sources, such as personal savings, pensions, investments.
Myth 3: A Spouse Always Receives 50% of Your Benefits
The idea that a spouse automatically receives half of the primary insured’s benefits is a common oversimplification. While the spousal benefit can be up to 50% of the Primary Insured’s, it varies based on when the spouse claims it.
– At age 62, the spousal benefit starts at 32.5% of the primary insured’s benefit (assuming he/she is not combining with their own PIA).
– It gradually increases until reaching the full 50% at Full Retirement Age (FRA)—66 years and 10 months for those claiming spousal benefits in 2025 and 67 for those claiming in 2026 or later.
Myth 4: You Should Claim Social Security as Early as Possible
While claiming Social Security at age 62 may make sense for some, it’s not a one-size-fits-all solution. Early claiming reduces your monthly benefits, while delaying increases them. For instance, claiming at 62 provides only 70% of your Full Retirement Age benefit, while waiting until 70 maximizes it at 124%.
Deciding when to claim depends on factors like your health, family longevity, financial needs, and whether you’re still working. Taking Social Security early without considering these factors could lead to regrets later.
Myth 5: Social Security Is a Ponzi Scheme
This myth arises from the fact that Social Security uses current workers’ contributions to fund retirees’ benefits—similar to how a Ponzi scheme pays earlier investors with new investors’ money. However, key differences debunk this claim:
- Transparency: The Social Security system is entirely transparent about its funding mechanisms and challenges, unlike a Ponzi scheme, which relies on secrecy.
- Enrichment: In a Ponzi scheme, the organizer is the one who benefits. Social Security benefits millions of Americans
- Longevity: A Ponzi scheme collapses when new contributions stop. Social Security can adjust through measures like raising taxes, increasing FRA, or modifying benefits.
For example, in 1982, the Social Security trust fund balance was just $24 billion, while annual payouts were $171 billion. Adjustments implemented in 1983 stabilized the system, and by 2020, the trust fund reached $2.9 trillion.
Myth 6: The Social Security Trust Fund Has Been Raided
Contrary to popular belief, the Social Security trust fund has not been “raided.” By law, trust fund assets must be invested in U.S. government securities, with interest and principal payments directed back into the fund.
While the government uses the fund from the issuance of these securities for general operations, the investments remain secure and accounted for, with interest payments ensuring the fund’s growth.
Conclusion
Misinformation about Social Security is rampant, but understanding the facts can help you make informed decisions. While the system faces challenges, its transparency and history of adjustments demonstrate its resilience. As you navigate your retirement planning, rely on credible sources and context to separate fact from fiction.
COMPANIES AND WEBSITES WE RECOMMEND AND SUPPORT
Plan Your Retirement With the Best Financial Planning Software I’ve Found
Get a two week FREE trial of Boldin (formerly NewRetirement) personal financial planning software – use our affiliate link* https://go.boldin.com/Schmidt to see if it’s for you.
Holy Schmidt! YouTube Channel
You can find over 300 of our retirement-related videos at: https://www.youtube.com/holyschmidt
(If you haven’t done so already, please make sure you Subscribe 🙂 ).
Center For Retirement Research at Boston College
CRR is one of the best websites if you want in depth retirement data – I use it frequently. You can find it here: https://crr.bc.edu/
*If you subscribe to Boldin, we earn a small fee. This does not increase your cost.
