Social Security.
Social Security is the monthly benefit you earned over a lifetime of work, and the single biggest claiming decision most people get wrong. Below are the 10 key parts that determine how much you actually collect: when to claim, how spousal and survivor benefits work, taxes, working while collecting Social Security, and more.
Email in your question
Send Geoff a question for his Tuesday livestream at 7:00 PM ET — simulcast on YouTube, Facebook, and X. Or catch the answer on his podcast, The Schmidt List.
THE TEN PARTS OF SOCIAL SECURITY
Open any topic. Geoff takes it from there.
WANT THE FULL WALKTHROUGH?
Important Social Security Topics
When to Claim
Deciding when to start your Social Security is one of the biggest money decisions you will make in retirement. You can claim as early as age 62 or as late as age 70, and the difference between those two choices can be hundreds, sometimes more than a thousand dollars a month for the rest of your life. This is the decision facing the primary insured, the person whose payment is based on their own earnings record. The challenge is that there is no single right answer. It depends on what you are trying to accomplish.
For some people the goal is the largest lifetime benefit, for others it is protecting a husband or wife. Some people are timing a specific event, like a mortgage payoff or a move. And some people simply need the money now and they have no other options.
Each of these goals points to a different claiming age. They do not all line up, and the choice that looks smart for one can work against another.
Full Retirement Age
Full Retirement Age (Normal Retirement Age) is the age at which you are entitled to 100% of the benefit you earned. It sounds like a simple number, but it is the hinge that almost every other Social Security decision turns on. You can claim as early as age 62, but your payment size will be smaller, though you will get more payments. You can also claim as late as age 70 and it will grow, but you will get fewer payments.
Almost everything you read about timing, including most of the benchmarks on the SSA website, is measured against your Full Retirement Age amount.
Getting the number right matters more than it looks. It sets the baseline for your own benefit and survivor benefits.
Spousal Benefits
If your husband or wife paid into Social Security, you can collect a monthly payment based on their earnings record, even if you never worked a day in your life. You just have to follow the rules, and for most people “the rules” are not that difficult. A lot of couples leave real money on the table simply because they did not know the benefit existed, or did not know how to coordinate the spousal benefit with the benefit from their own work history (if applicable).
The spousal benefit can be a meaningful share of what your family receives in retirement. But whether you get it, how much you get, and when you should claim it all depend on a handful of simple rules that trip people up constantly.
Another big opportunity is in how the two benefits work together. When one spouse is the higher earner, the timing of their benefit and the timing of the spousal benefit can be coordinated to fit your family’s goals, whether that means more income early, a larger survivor benefit later, or the most you can collect as a couple over your lifetimes. These are separate decisions, and they pull in different directions.
Get the sequence right and you can shape your household income for years, sometimes for the rest of your lives. Get it wrong and you give up money you were entitled to.
Survivor Benefits
When a husband or wife dies, the surviving spouse can often receive the higher of the two Social Security payments the couple was receiving.
This is one of the most important and least understood benefits of Social Security: who qualifies, how much they receive, and when they can start are governed by the survivor benefit’s own set of rules, which are not the same as those for the spousal benefit.
Timing matters more than most people realize. The age at which the higher earner claimed during their lifetime can shape the survivor payment for years afterward. And a survivor sometimes has choices of their own, including the option to take one benefit now and switch to another later, which can mean a meaningfully larger income over time.
Divorced-Spouse Benefits
If you were married for at least 10 years and are now divorced, you may be able to collect a monthly payment based on your former husband’s or wife’s earnings record, even if you never worked a day in your life. Many people never claim it simply because they did not know a divorce can leave this door open.
You do not need your ex’s approval or sign-off, and you do not have to involve them at all. Your claim also takes nothing away from them. It does not reduce their own payment, and it does not reduce the spousal benefit going to their new husband or wife. The money you collect is in addition to all of that, not carved out of it.
The payment can be a meaningful share of what you live on in retirement. But whether you qualify, how much you get, and when you can claim all depend on a handful of rules.
Tax on Social Security
A lot of people are surprised to learn that the Social Security they worked their whole lives to earn can be taxed all over again once they start collecting it, even though they paid their own Social Security tax with after-tax income. Not everyone pays this tax, and a lot of it comes down to the rest of your retirement income and how you manage it.
Two people with the exact same Social Security payment can owe very different amounts simply because of how the rest of their money is arranged.
This is where some real planning comes in. The order in which you draw from your accounts, and the timing of larger moves like conversions or big withdrawals, can change how much of your benefit ends up taxed, sometimes for years at a stretch. Decisions you make in one year can raise or lower the tax in the next.
Working While Collecting Social Security
The SSA has specific limits on how much you can earn while collecting Social Security. It is called the earnings test. If you claim before your Full Retirement Age and keep working, Social Security can hold back part of your payment. How much can you earn? It changes every year and in your first year of collecting it is measured monthly, because most people do not retire on January 1, and someone who worked the first half of the year and stopped midyear could otherwise be caught by a limit measured across the whole year. The SSA sets the limits, and if you go over them, the amount held back is not lost. It comes back to you later in the form of a larger payment.
Cost-of-Living Adjustment (COLA)
Almost every year, the Social Security Administration raises your payment to help it keep pace with rising prices. This is called the cost-of-living adjustment, or COLA, and it is the reason a longtime recipient’s payment is larger today than it was when they first claimed. In some years the raise is sizable. In others it is barely there. And in a rare year, there is no raise at all.
The COLA is not set by Congress voting on it each year, and it is not tied to how much your own personal costs went up. It is calculated from a specific government measure of inflation, and that measure does not always match what retirees actually feel at the grocery store or the pharmacy.
A bigger COLA can also push up the cost of your Medicare premium in the same year, so part of the raise can be absorbed before it ever reaches your bank account. The headline number and the amount you actually keep are not always the same thing.
SSDI (Social Security Disability Insurance)
SSDI is the Social Security program that pays a monthly benefit to people who can no longer work because of a serious medical condition. It is not a handout and it is not welfare. You earn it the same way you earn your retirement benefit, by working and paying Social Security taxes over the years. If a disability cuts your career short, this is the coverage those taxes paid for.
Qualifying is sometimes difficult, however. Social Security uses a strict definition of disability, and the condition generally has to keep you from working and be expected to last at least a year or to result in death. Knowing how the process works before you start can make a real difference.
SSDI connects to other benefits, including what it means for your family, for Medicare, and for your retirement benefit once you reach Full Retirement Age. The pieces fit together in a specific order, and getting them in the right order matters.
Supplemental Security Income (SSI)
SSI is often confused with Social Security, but it is a different program with a different purpose. It pays a monthly benefit to people who are 65 or older, blind, or disabled and who have very little income and very few assets. Unlike your retirement benefit or SSDI, you do not earn SSI by working and paying into the system. It is based on financial need, which means the rules look at what you own and what you bring in, not at your work history.
There are limits on how much you can have in savings and other resources, and certain kinds of help from family can actually count against you.
SSI also overlaps with other benefits. You can sometimes receive it alongside a small Social Security payment, and in most states qualifying for SSI opens the door to Medicaid.
Get Geoff's Course: Social Security Simplified
Knowing the rules and knowing what to do are two different things.
This is the framework Geoff uses to turn one into the other: when to claim, how to coordinate with a spouse, what the earnings test does if you keep working, and how much of the benefit the tax code takes back. Every lesson is plain English and third-grade math, with a workbook that puts your own numbers in front of you.
Most people get one shot at this decision. This is how you make it the right one. 23 videos, 15 modules · 103 Page Workbook – self-paced
- Social Security
- Retirement Planning
- CALCULATORS & TOOLS